The inestimable William Greider has been wrestling with many of the topics the rest of us have — how to deal politically with this obviously new world. We are solidly post-Bush, and Obama has not brought forth the Change that he promised and progressives wanted. In many ways, he's dug us in deeper.
Greider's latest is "The End of New Deal Liberalism", a cover article in the January 24 issue of The Nation. Thankfully, the whole thing is available on the web without subscription.
I consider it an important piece and recommend reading it in full. It's longer than I can excerpt fairly and covers much territory that people who know my views will find familiar. Here's the opening (my emphasis throughout):
We have reached a pivotal moment in government and politics, and it feels like the last, groaning spasms of New Deal liberalism. When the party of activist government, faced with an epic crisis, will not use government's extensive powers to reverse the economic disorders and heal deepening social deterioration, then it must be the end of the line for the governing ideology inherited from Roosevelt, Truman and Johnson.No words were minced in the writing of his article. It's a cogent analysis and makes its point with all of Greider's knowledge and skill. In addition, it's prominently placed in The Nation, in the issue on newsstands just prior to Obama's State of the Union address. (That in itself is comment-worthy; the piece could be considered a shot-across-his-bow message from The Nation to Obama.)
Political events of the past two years have delivered a more profound and devastating message: American democracy has been conclusively conquered by American capitalism. Government has been disabled or captured by the formidable powers of private enterprise and concentrated wealth. Self-governing rights that representative democracy conferred on citizens are now usurped by the overbearing demands of corporate and financial interests. Collectively, the corporate sector has its arms around both political parties, the financing of political careers, the production of the policy agendas and propaganda of influential think tanks, and control of most major media.
What the capitalist system wants is more—more wealth, more freedom to do whatever it wishes. This has always been its instinct, unless government intervened to stop it. The objective now is to destroy any remaining forms of government interference, except of course for business subsidies and protections. ... A lot of Americans seem to know this; at least they sense that the structural reality of government and politics is not on their side. ... In these terms, the administration of Barack Obama has been a crushing disappointment for those of us who hoped he would be different. It turns out Obama is a more conventional and limited politician than advertised, more right-of-center than his soaring rhetoric suggested. Most Congressional Democrats, likewise, proved weak and incoherent, unreliable defenders of their supposed values[.]
But I'd like to focus here on Greider's conclusion, in which he offers a plan. His suggestions:
I suggest three steps for progressives to recover an influential role in politics. First, develop a guerrilla sensibility that recognizes the weakness of the left.Here he discusses the success of the Tea Party in shaping GOP politics by holding Daddy Warbuck's feet to the virtual fire. The important word here is Primaries. Need I say more?
Second, people of liberal persuasion should "go back to school" and learn the new economic realities ... a fundamental re-examination of capitalism and the relationship between the state and the private sphere. This will not be done by business-financed think tanks.The New Deal fixed an old world. It's a new world now, Greider argues. To solve its problems, we have to learn its dynamics. He sees working people as the potential "new center of a reinvigorated democracy" but notes that there's no guarantee that working and middle class reaction will be left-oriented.
I will add, on this point, that we not only have to learn, we also have to learn how to teach in this new world. I've written on that before and stand by those thoughts.
Finally, left-liberals need to start listening and learning—talking up close to ordinary Americans, including people who are not obvious allies.Again, you have to be able to listen in order to teach. The real split in this country is not left-right. But it's being sold as left-right to keep the confused from seeing the game, from seeing whose hand is really in their pocket. The more we fight the right-wing followers (as opposed to their leaders), the more we confirm to the followers that we are their enemy. Very bad idea. Better to listen and talk, to and not at, tough as that sounds to do. (No one promised the best tactics would be the most fun, folks.)
And I'll add another point — we have no time to waste. Once the bank is fully robbed, teaching the guards who to watch for doesn't count for much.
All in all, a great read. And one that would make a great starting point for a panel at Netroots Nation (coming soon to a Minneapolis near you), should someone be inclined to suggest it. I know I will.
GP
