I was reading Dana Milbank's piece today, mentioning how if health care reform does not pass, millions of uninsured will have to wait till another time, and it got me thinking that, yet again, Democrats and their supporters need to stop talking about health care reform as if it were only meant to help the thousands of uninsured. For the rest of America, that sounds like a welfare bill that doesn't benefit them. Here's why I think so.
Our country is in the greatest economic crisis since the Great Depression. Most of us weren't around back then, so this is the biggest, scariest economic situation we've seen in our lifetimes. The biggest concern many of us, probably most Americans, have is surviving the next few years with our homes, our families, and our lives, in tact. While an economic crisis is the very time we should be most worried about the most unfortunate among us - e.g., those without health insurance because they're too poor, unemployed, or because plans are simply too expensive - those are the people that the majority of Americans, I believe, care least about at this time.
Why? Because in times of crisis you worry most about yourself and your own family. When you're worried about paying your own mortgage, you don't think "hey, maybe if I spend a little more money I can help some stranger halfway across the country." But that, I fear, is how too many health care advocates are spinning reform. As some trillion dollar program that won't benefit the majority of Americans at all, but rather, as a program for the unfortunate. And while Americans can be generous to those less fortunate during times of plenty, I don't think it's the wisest way to woo someone whose 401k has lost nearly half its value in the past year.
Most people have had problems at some point with their health coverage, or they know someone who has. It shouldn't be rocket science to get people concerned about how paltry their own health coverage really is, especially when their jobs (i.e., health care) are far from secure, and far too many of us are only one serious disease away from bankruptcy.
When times are tough people get selfish. It's time to appeal to their greed, not their charity. Charity, I fear, went out the window half a 401k ago.
Elections | Economic Crisis | Jobs | TSA | Limbaugh | Fun Stuff
Follow @americablog
Its not the uninsured, stupid
More posts about:
health care
blog comments powered by Disqus