Karl Rove is planning on address one of the largest Latino organizations, La Raza, tomorrow in California. In commemoration of the Bush administration's new-found love for the same Latinos they wanted to kick out of the country last week, with the help of a friend who put the following list together, let's take a way down memory lane, shall we:
Rove’s Outreach to Hispanic Voters
Today, Karl Rove will address the National Council of La Raza. Unfortunately, his grand strategy to attract Hispanic voters to the Republican Party is in jeopardy because of a revolt of House Republicans on immigration. Will the Bush Administration be able to go beyond their campaign rhetoric and really reach out to Hispanic voters? Accomplishing this task will require standing up to the right wing of the Republican Party. Unfortunately, Bush and his Administration have been better at talking the talk of reaching out than they have been of walking the walk.
THEN: Bush Campaigned in Spanish
In Davenport, Iowa: ''La Sueño Americano.” “Over a breakfast of burritos and beans at a neon-colored Jalapeño Mexican Cuisine in Davenport, Iowa, this summer, Bush spoke of his goal that everyone share in ''la sueño Americano.'' [The Miami Herald, 10/9/99]
In Los Angeles, California: Ingles y Mas: “As Bush addressed a crowd of 3,000 last week at the Latin Business Association in Los Angeles, he signaled his sensitivity. 'Ingles solamente' isn't the way, Bush said. Instead of English only, the goal is Ingles y mas, English and more. 'Children of any background should not be used as pawns in bitter debates on education and immigration.’'' [The Miami Herald, 9/9/99]
In Chicago, Milwaukee, and Philadelphia, Bush Sang the National Anthem in Spanish. "When visiting cities like Chicago, Milwaukee, or Philadelphia, in pivotal states, Bush would drop in at Hispanic festivals and parties, sometimes joining in singing 'The Star-Spangled Banner' in Spanish, sometimes partying with a 'Viva Bush’ mariachi band flown in from Texas." [American Dynasty, Kevin Phillips]
NOW: Bush Says the National Anthem Ought to Be Sung in English.
Bush: “I think the national anthem ought to be sung in English, and I think people who want to be a citizen of this country ought to learn English and they ought to learn to sing the national anthem in English.” [4/28/06]
THEN: Undocumented Mexicans Who Had Crossed Illegally Were “Hard-Working Citizens”.
Bush: “We share values with Mexico. They’re common values — values that unite people, whether they live in the United States or whether they live in Mexico. And what are those values? … The willingness to work hard. America is known for our ability to work hard. Think about the Mexican worker who walks 500 miles across a desert to find work. Those are hard-working citizens. We share that very important value of people willing to roll up their sleeves and work hard.” [White House, 9/6/01]
NOW: Terrorists, Drug Dealers, and Criminals Sneak into the United States.
Bush: “To defend this country, we have to enforce our borders. When our borders are not secure, terrorists, drug dealers, and criminals find it easier to sneak into America. My administration has a clear strategy for dealing with this problem: We want to stop people from crossing into America illegally, and to quickly return the illegal immigrants we catch back to their home countries.” [White House, 10/22/05]
THEN: Bush Floated the Idea of Amnesty.
Bush – as Part of an Effort to Woo Latino Voters – Floated the idea of an Amnesty. “Since arriving in Washington, President George W. Bush has persisted in believing that the GOP can engineer a major shift in US. electoral politics and seize a sizable chunk of a voting bloc that the Democrats have come to assume is solidly loyal. Using Cabinet picks and tailoring policy -- including floating the idea of granting an amnesty to more than 3 million Mexicans living in the United States illegally -- the president has continued with a high-profile effort to woo skeptical Latinos away from the Democrats.” [Washington Times, 10/1/01]
NOW: Bush Wavers on Comprehensive Reform
The Bush Administration Issued a Statement of Administration Policy in Support of the Sensenbrenner Immigration Bill – a Bill that Would Make Felons of Undocumented Workers.
Bush Shows Signs of Wavering on Comprehensive Reform. “Republicans both inside and outside the White House say Mr. Bush, who has long insisted on comprehensive reform, is now open to a so-called enforcement-first approach that would put new border security programs in place before creating a guest worker program or path to citizenship for people living in the United States illegally.” [New York Times, 7/5/06]
Republicans Predict Bush Will Abandon the Path to Citizenship. “But one Republican close to the White House, granted anonymity to discuss internal deliberations, predicted that Mr. Bush would ultimately abandon the idea of a path to citizenship.” [New York Times, 7/5/06]
THEN: Karl Rove Outlined a Strategy to Attract Hispanic Voters
Karl Rove Outlines the Strategy: “Mission and Goal” is to Attract Latino Voters. “The broad statistics and the doubts, though, aren't deterring the White House. Earlier in the year Karl Rove, the president's senior political adviser, told reporters in Washington that grabbing a bigger share of the Latino vote is "our mission and our goal" and that it will require the effort of all Republicans "in every way and every day working to get that done." [Washington Times, 10/1/01]
For Rove – It’s about the Math. “Rove sees the math as simple: For the president to get re-elected the Republicans need to keep competitive in voter-rich states such as Illinois, where an increasing Latino presence threatens to make the political environment friendlier for Democratic candidates, RNC campaign strategists tell Insight. Bush needs to ensure a win in Florida and focus on several smaller states where Latino numbers are gaining -- states such as North Carolina, Iowa and Oregon.” [Washington Times, 10/01/01]
Bush Political Operation Understands the Importance of the Hispanic Vote. "We got 35 percent of the Hispanic vote" in the last election, RNC spokesman Trent Duffy recently told Insight. ‘If we don't get that up to 38 or 40 percent, it's all over.’ Matthew Dowd, a Bush adviser in last year's election campaign, has chorused regularly in sessions with Rove that more must be done on the Hispanic front, White House sources say. [Washington Times, 10/01/01]
Rove Set the Strategy. “Going into the campaign, chief White House political strategist Karl Rove stated he wanted to increase the President’s share of the Hispanic electorate from 35% in 2000 to at least 40% in 2004.” [Washington Times, 11/10/04]
In 2004, Rove’s Political Operation Met its Goal for Attracting the Hispanic Vote. “In the 2004 election, the Hispanic vote really did matter—particularly in the race for the White House. An estimated 9 million Hispanics cast ballots—more than ever before. According to exit polls, President Bush won as much as 44 percent of the Hispanic vote—improving on the 35 percent he received in 2000 and breezing past the stated goal of White House senior adviser Karl Rove, who had said he’d be happy with 40 percent.” [Dallas Morning News, Editorial, 11/9/04]
NOW: Because of House Republicans, Rove’s Strategy is in Jeopardy
Immigration Threatens Bush Inroads with Hispanic Voters. “If Hispanics bolt the GOP because of immigration, it would erase the inroads George W. Bush has made in opening the party to the group, both as Texas governor and president. What's more, a strong Latino turnout could help Democrats win control of Congress in the November elections and change the landscape in the next presidential race.” [Dallas Morning News, 5/6/06]
House Republicans Jeopardize Bush’s Plans to Draw Latino Voters to the Republican Party. “By pushing English-only policies and tough measures against illegal immigrants, House conservatives are endangering President Bush's goal of drawing millions of Latino voters to the Republican Party and helping realign ethnic politics for years to come, according to an array of analysts and officials.” [Washington Post, 6/30/06]
House Republicans Are Blocking the Renewal of the Voting Rights Act. “The latest blow to Bush's efforts to woo Hispanics came last week, when a band of House Republicans unexpectedly balked at renewing the 1965 Voting Rights Act, partly because of a 30-year-old requirement that many local governments provide bilingual ballots. The revolt, which forced House GOP leaders to abruptly postpone a vote, came as House Republicans are stiffening their resistance to Bush's bid to allow pathways to legal status for millions of illegal immigrants while also strengthening borders and deportation efforts. [Washington Post, 6/30/06]
Bottom Line: The Rove Strategy Isn’t Working
According to the Latino Policy Coalition, Bush has a 28 percent approval rate among Latinos and the GOP Congress has a 23 percent approval rate. “Latino voters are making up their minds earlier in the mid-term election cycle and trust Democrats to do a better job than Republicans on issues such as health care, economic issues facing families, education and immigration, according to a survey released today by the non-partisan Latino Policy Coalition (LPC). The extensive survey, conducted by Lake Research Partners in 23 states across the U.S., also found Latino voters overwhelmingly dissatisfied with the job performances of both President Bush and the Republican-led Congress.”
